The Church’s Superior, Successful Part

2/3

Hatty Calbus

                   Simon Hattenstone, in an interview with Rupert Everett, described the boarding school in Julian Mitchell’s Another Country as “dominated by the three Bs: bullying, bigotry and buggery” (sorry). The bigotry is part of an elite tribalism. The 2020 IICSA report identified tribalism as a significant Anglican failing. Nick Duffell observes that those from such schools are likely to “continue to live lives in the shelter of institutions where boarding survivors feel most at home, such as the City, the Bar, the Army, nowadays the media, or even Parliament.” He could have added the ministry. Fiona Gardner cite studies which confirm that “a significant percentage of clergy … and the greater part of the senior leadership of the church were educated privately.” The “embedded cultural ethos of the public school” present in the church hierarchy and historically so riddled with abuse, mostly means boarding school, as day school pupils often have UB parents and teachers.

Abigail Frymann Rouch, assessing the Makin Review, noted that “the long-maintained conspiracy of silence” around Smyth was strongly determined by social class. These were people used, from school, to accepting, not just abusive behaviour, but crimes. Charles Spencer details teachers silently colluding with vicious perverts. UB loyalty to the tribe no matter what is summed up in Yes, Prime Minister: “They seemed like decent chaps. And decent chaps don’t check up on decent chaps to see if they’re behaving like decent chaps.”

Some UBs are nice, even very nice, and more obviously walking wounded. But there is a very common type with supreme confidence hiding, as Duffell says, “emotional and relational dysfunction behind a façade.” Over-entitlement can be smoothed by what Tom Hiddleston called “a toolkit of manners and politeness and charm.” That self-assured toolkit, rarely unaccompanied by career success, is persuasive to the point of staying widely unquestioned. David Cameron famously said he wanted to be Prime Minister because he thought he’d be good at it and made no plans for losing the referendum. Boris Johnson’s initial confidently-casual response to Covid was found by the the official enquiry to have caused twenty-three thousand deaths (and many times that in bereavements).

The toolkit’s persuasiveness is driven by its possessors’ belief in their exceptionalism, a belief learned at school. Ministry to such men has meant running the Church rather than the country, with faith in God – but also their right to power. In Mortal Spoils Anglican novelist DM Greenwood refers to “the impermeable, ignorant smugness of senior clergy,” some of whom could be seen in the House of Lords chortling at Justin Welby’s bitter resignation wisecracks.

The tribe is bonded by damaged psyches – yet better than everyone else. That bond of unprocessed trauma joined to compensatory grandiosity means those outside become a separate, lesser species. A friend who faced his boarding school damage pointed to numerous ways of labelling this species: the masses, the lower orders, the great unwashed, hoi polloi, plebs, proles etc. Christianity often makes minimal difference to UB over-entitlement (see Cameron and Johnson). The priest who groomed and sexually assaulted me when I was a teenager also explained the crucial U and non-U difference between such binaries as perfume/scent, serviette/napkin and dessert/pudding – French being no replacement for breeding.

The most blatant snobbery I’ve ever encountered, was serving food for HTB’s Alpha Courses. At a few drinks parties to thank us, clergy circulated with canapés, but there was a certain de haut en bas attitude to those doing menial tasks, as if we were help from the village. Unlike other organisations, they didn’t seek volunteers’ feedback. Wanting to try helping in a small group, I was told, “We ask people we know.” I was there every week, often till 10.30 at night, yet it was so very clear what he meant. Once Pippa Gumbel put a cup on the tray I was carrying past without even looking. While I should see this as good for the humility, it was hardly Christian.

While most victims of historical clergy child abuse are men, most victims of abuse overall, including adult clergy abuse, are women and, as Duffell says, “The boarding system has an added inbuilt and serious problem with females: they are utterly absent, except in a service role.” While most UB clergy are not predators, patronising and bullying are common. At HTB, middle aged volunteers were addressed as ‘Girls’. Anne Atkins attended Iwerne summer camps: “We were confined to the kitchen bashing spuds. The men, glorious in the sunshine and their cream cricket sweaters, played sports; gave talks in the meetings; swam and batted and even I believe flew aeroplanes.”  https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ 2017/02/03/anne-atkins-inside-thesexual-apartheid-john-smyths-summer-camps Spencer notes the lack of respect for female staff at his prep school, who weren’t granted names, with the boys instructed to address them only as “Please.”

And there are other races. After several dozen former pupils and staff at Dulwich College alleged incidences of racism against Nigel Farage, which he both denied and excused, https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/nigel-farage-racism-antisemitic-comments-classmates-b2871578.html an anonymous letter in the Guardian said, ““Many others from a similar background – were schooled in an environment that condoned or even encouraged blatant racism, while also equipping the pupils with the swagger, charm and polish to make others feel inferior and admiring of them. To see him in isolation is to miss the nature of the sorts of institutions that educated him, and the damage they do. I’m sure the schools will say they have changed, and I hope they have, but while they continue to educate their pupils to believe they are better than others, there will be plenty more where Farage came from.” https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2025/nov/26/racism-claims-against-nigel-farage-are-no-surprise-to-us?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

Inferiors even include clergy. Cris Rogers wrote, “As a working-class clergyman, I have often had to learn to navigate, with much confusion, a middle- and upper-class church.” He carried out a survey of four hundred and thirty-four working-class clergy and reported that “Shockingly, only three respondents felt that they were trusted or understood, and a mere seven believed that they were seen as equal.” https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2024/5-july/comment/opinion/do-clergy-have-to-stop-being-working-class This is the dominant mindset of the Church’s hierarchy and HTB’s influential Revitalise Trust.

The obstacles between it and Christianity are considerable, but there are workarounds. Charity is common – but bestowing from one’s height. It is only putting it slightly too crudely to say that to a significant part of the Church, those not upper or upper middle class are seen as oiks to be magnanimous to.

In this superiority, Duffell writes that a boarder is expected to become “a doer, leader, professional, achiever, winner, manager, boss” with “a tendency to overvalue work or achievements.” Armando Iannucci and Stewart Lee on the podcast Strong Message Here criticised leadership talk in politics as “self-aggrandising and macho.” In the Church that talk has a veneer that comes from public school superiority, not God. It is not Scripture that explains HTB’s excessive focus on ‘leading’. It has been pointed out that ‘leadership’ has replaced ministry – also that ‘leader’ appears in Scripture seven times, ‘disciple ‘ 260. Richard Moth, on his appointment as Archbishop of Westminster, was asked how he would avoid the vice of clericalism. He replied, “Service.” While the Borgias did, admittedly, miss this one, the Pope is, officially, “servant of the servants of God.” In contrast, the blurb for HTB’s 2025  leadership conference (“LC25”)  was, “The world is changed through leadership” – whose enthusiasts rarely see themselves among the led.

In an interview with Freddie Sayers of UnHerd, Rowan Williams said he was worried about a church “too preoccupied with strategy — with schemes for solving problems — and not preoccupied enough with its own integrity as a community of witness and prayer.” He linked over-bureaucratisation with control and even said it was demonic.

This control is the descendant of the muscular Christianity that ran the Empire. God’s power isn’t falsely strong, however. Angela Tilby writes, “Biblical leaders (think of Abraham, Moses, Miriam, Samuel, David, John the Baptist, Peter, Mary the mother of Jesus, and Mary Magdalene) often seem surprised to be called by God. With the call comes a task, a commission, for which they often feel inadequate.” Yet HTB, via its conferences and Revitalise Trust, is super-confident in its leadership expertise and qualification to pass that on.

It is easy to see why leading and achievement-focused Church managerialism appeal to UBs cut off from so much of themselves. Uninterested in the whole person – themselves or others – which would make them vulnerable, they need the control of leading and measurable achievement. Christianity is not about control and achievement.

In worldly terms Jesus failed.  But Evangelical UBs have a cover for their compulsion to achieve: the importance of evangelising. Of course there are Christian UBs whose superiority includes their spirituality, for example, BCP devotees who look down on Evangelicals, but Evangelicalism, with its focus on looking outwards, is ideal for UBs. That does not mean there is nothing genuine in their spirituality, but it is undermined by buried motives. Jesus said, “Go and make disciples of all nations.” He did not say, “And use that as a way to avoid yourselves.”

In my next article, I shall look at the destructive defences of superior, in-control UBs confronted with the vulnerability of abuse.

https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2024/5-july/comment/opinion/do-clergy-have-to-stop-being-working-class

About Stephen Parsons

Stephen is a retired Anglican priest living at present in Cumbria. He has taken a special interest in the issues around health and healing in the Church but also when the Church is a place of harm and abuse. He has published books on both these issues and is at present particularly interested in understanding how power works at every level in the Church. He is always interested in making contact with others who are concerned with these issues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.